How Much to Spend on an Engagement Ring?
You have found the soulmate that you would like to spend the rest of your life with – congratulations! Now comes another big decision: the engagement ring. From the old “three months’ salary rule” to the stunning social media posts and kind advice from friends and family on how much to spend, the whole process of determining the amount ends up being overwhelming. Take a deep breath. The perfect ring budget is not a formula or what someone else paid; it is about what is right for your relationship, is based on your values, and can meet your budget.
Factors That Should Guide Your Engagement Ring Budget
Your engagement ring symbolizes your commitment, but that symbolism shouldn’t be accompanied by a financial strain that follows you even into the marriage. When determining what is reasonable, for your situation, consider the following key factors;
Personal Financial Situation
Your current financial landscape should be the primary consideration. This includes:
- Income stability: Is your employment secure? Are you expecting any significant changes to your income?
- Savings: How might this purchase affect your emergency fund?
- Existing debt: Student loans, credit cards, or car payments already creating monthly obligations?
- Financial goals: Are you saving for a home down payment or planning to start a family soon?
Remember, an engagement ring is just one step on your road together. The most valuable ring is not one that would jeopardize your common financial future.
Partner's Expectations and Values
Some partners dream of a specific style or stone size, while others may prioritize experiences over material items. Consider:
- Has your partner dropped hints about preferences?
- Do they wear minimal jewellery or statement pieces?
- Would they prefer investing in your honeymoon or future home instead of a larger diamond?
The most cherished rings reflect the wearer’s personality and values—not just a price point.
Lifestyle Considerations
Your partner’s daily activities and habits should influence your choice:
- Do their career or hobbies involve hands-on work?
- Are they active in sports or outdoor activities?
- How comfortable are they wearing valuable items daily?
Someone with an active lifestyle might appreciate a lower-profile setting with a more secure stone placement over a larger, more prominently set diamond.
Future Expenses
An engagement is just the beginning of your life together. Consider what’s coming next:
- Wedding costs
- Honeymoon expenses
- Housing goals (saving for a down payment)
- Family planning costs
The most thoughtful ring purchase considers both the excitement of today and the dreams of tomorrow.
Average Engagement Ring Costs (and Why They Vary)
Understanding the market might allow you to round off your decision with a little context, but your budget should never be based on averages alone.
The average price of engagement rings is about $5,000 -$ 6,000 in Canada and around $5,500 -$ 6,000 in the U.S. That figure increases to $7,500+ in metropolitan cities like Toronto.
These figures differ drastically depending on several factors:
- Geographic location: Urban centers typically see higher average spending than rural areas.
- Diamond specifications: The diamond 4Cs (cut, colour, clarity, carat) create exponential price differences.
- Brand premium: Designer and luxury jewellers command higher prices for their reputations and craftsmanship.
- Custom vs. ready-made: Bespoke designs typically involve higher costs but allow for personalization.
- Metal choice: Platinum can be a perfect metal for engagement ring which costs significantly more than 14k gold.
Remember that averages include both $500 rings and $50,000 rings—what matters is finding your comfortable place on that spectrum.
How to Set a Realistic Budget (Without Guilt)
Creating a budget you feel confident about requires honest reflection and communication.
Start by determining what you can comfortably afford without:
- Depleting emergency savings
- Accumulating high-interest debt
- Creating financial anxiety
- Compromising imminent needs
If you are keen on specific features but your budget is tightening, go for quality rather than volume. A beautiful half-carat diamond, if cut well, can outshine an inferior cut of a larger stone.
Consider alternative options that align with your values and budget:
- Lab-grown diamonds (chemically identical to mined diamonds at 30-40% less cost)
- Moissanite or white sapphire (beautiful alternatives with different optical properties)
- Vintage or estate pieces (often more unique with competitive pricing)
Most importantly, remember that the ring is just one element of your love story. The proposal moment, the life you’re building, and the meaning behind the ring matter far more than meeting an arbitrary spending threshold.
Ways to Maximize Your Budget
Smart shopping strategies can help you get the most value, regardless of your budget:
Strategic Shopping
- Compare retailers: Online jewellers often have lower overhead costs than brick-and-mortar stores, potentially saving 20-40%.
- Timing matters: Industry sales often occur after major proposal holidays (Valentine’s Day, Christmas).
- Independent jewellers: Consider independent jewellers in Toronto like Serli & Siroan, who offer personalized service and often better value than chain stores.
Wise Diamond Selection
- Prioritize cut quality: This factor has more impact on sparkle than any other factor; an excellent-cut diamond will light up more than a poorly-cut, bigger stone.
- Choose shapes wisely: Oval, pear and marquise shapes look larger than round diamonds of the same carat weight.
- Consider the “magic sizes”: A 0.9-carat diamond is usually perceivably indistinguishable from a 1-carat diamond, but is much cheaper as a result of psychological pricing thresholds.
- Adjust clarity strategically: Many inclusions are invisible to the naked eye—an SI1 clarity diamond can look identical to a VVS1 at a fraction of the cost.
Setting Enhancements
- Halo settings: In Halo setting, it surround a center stone with smaller diamonds to create the illusion of a larger diamond.
- Cathedral settings: Elevate the center stone to create a more prominent appearance.
- Three-stone settings: Distribute your engagement ring budget across multiple smaller stones for greater overall impact.
Imagine your partner’s face lighting up as they see a perfectly proportioned diamond that catches light from every angle—that sparkle comes from quality craftsmanship and thoughtful selection, not just spending more.
Should You Finance an Engagement Ring?
Financing options can make your dream ring more accessible, but require careful consideration:
Potential Benefits
- Immediate purchase: Get the ring now rather than waiting months or years to save.
- Cash flow management: Smaller monthly payments instead of one large sum.
- Possible promotions: Many jewellers offer interest-free periods (typically 6-12 months).
Important Cautions
- Interest costs: Once promotional periods end, interest rates often jump to 20 %+ APR.
- Commitment timeline: Monthly payments could extend well into your marriage.
- Psychological impact: Starting your engagement with debt can create stress.
Responsible Financing Approaches
If financing makes sense for your situation:
- Read the fine print: Understand exactly when interest kicks in and at what rate.
- Calculate the total cost: This includes all interest and fees over the payment period.
- Create a repayment plan: Aim to pay off the ring before any promotional interest period ends.
- Consider alternative financing: A personal loan from a credit union might offer better terms than jewellery store financing.
The most loving choice is one you can truly afford. A smaller ring purchased responsibly often brings more joy than a larger one that creates financial tension in your relationship.
Frequently Asked Questions
An amount that will comfortably fit your finances yet fulfil the expectations of your partner. There’s no universal “correct” amount—the right number is personal to your relationship and circumstances.
This guideline was based on a marketing campaign from the 1930s and not financial prudence. Modern couples rely on personal values and financial objectives to make their decisions instead of old formulas.
In Canada, the average is about $5,000-$6,000 whereas big cities such as Toronto are at $7,500+.
Remember that averages include extreme ends of the spectrum.
Absolutely! Through attention to cut quality, consideration of other shapes, or entering the realm of lab-grown diamonds, you can find gorgeous quality rings at this price point that will sparkle a lifetime.
Financing can be appropriate if you qualify for truly interest-free terms and have a solid repayment plan. However, saving up often creates less financial stress in your new life together.
The right partner cares more about the thought, meaning, and sustainability of your choice than its price tag. True love appreciates responsible financial decisions.
Quality, particularly cut, contributes more to a diamond’s beauty and sparkle than size alone. A well-cut, smaller diamond will outshine a larger, poor-quality stone every time.
Get in Touch
Loved one of the styles above but want it customized. Email us below with the style, your desired metal and gemstone colour and we will make it happen!